Sunday, October 21, 2007

Location Efficient Mortgages

In "New Energy for Cities" the section "Build High-Performance Cities" mentions Location Efficient Mortgages (LEMs). Pioneered in Chicago, LEMs promote transit-oriented development as well as affordable housing. The Apollo Alliance recognizes that TOD's can often been priced too high for low to moderate income (LMI) families. According to Apollo "LEMs allow homebuyers to capitalize on the savings that result from living near transit service ... by calculating these savings into the purchasing power of the homebuyer." (p 37) LEMs can add increased borrowing power of $30,000 to $50,000. Currently LEMs exist in Chicago, SF, Seattle, LA and Madison, WI. I'll follow this synopsis with a more in-depth look at LEMs and then an outline of Chicago's CityMortgage Initiative, which is highlighted in the Apollo Text.
From the website locationefficiency.com
Welcome!

You may qualify for a home mortgage when you thought you couldn't or be eligible for a larger loan than you expected based on the purchase of a home in a location efficient community.

The Location Efficient Mortgage®‚ (LEM) is a mortgage that helps people become homeowners in location efficient communities. These are convenient neighborhoods in which residents can walk from their homes to stores, schools, recreation, and public transportation. People who live in location efficient communities have less need to drive, which allows them to save money and improves the environment for everyone.

The LEM combines a low down payment, competitive interest rates, and flexible criteria for financial qualification to allow more people to own the home of their dreams.

Further studying the FAQ's and other areas of the website cited in the Apollo guide I became increasingly aware that although this might be a powerful incentive tool for people of middle income to locate to TOD's the LEM does not appear to be that powerful a tool for low to moderate income families, as recorded by Apollo. Within the metropolitan areas I have mentioned, just from my own knowledge, for low to moderate income families to settle in new center city developments, they would need a more substantial subsidy program towards housing. LEM's appear to be more of a program to incentivize people to locate in TOD's (not a bad thing of course) but not really a promotion of affordable housing as Apollo writes.

My impression from the locationefficiency.com website was substantiated by my research of CityMortgage in Chicago - which actually makes no mention outright of LEM's on the city's website, only that competitive mortgage rates are available through the city. However, through the Center for Neighborhood Technology (also mentioned in Apollo) there is information available on Chicago's attempt to combine transportation and affordability. http://www.cnt.org/ht/

This website acknowledges that as transportation and housing are the largest expenses for many families there should be a way of combining the two. LEM's do address that issue but it appears they have not had the effect that was hoped. Note: although this was not directly based on energy efficiency, I was intrigued by LEM's as a powerful tool for promoting affordable housing at TOD's and so I decided to give this further exploration.
Sources:
http://www.locationefficiency.com/
http://www.locationefficiency.com/faq
http://www.cnt.org/ht/

Renewables----GREAT STUFF

I was very glad to learn of our new assignment last week as the origin of my interest in green cities was in renewable energy. There is such a huge amount of work being done in this area and it’s about time we delve into it. I see there is one major issue with renewable energy today.

The government.

For decades different types of energy which can be considered renewable (solar, wind, and hydrogen), and clean but not quite renewable (geothermal and nuclear) have been available. Only recently however we are seeing the emergence of these resources becoming mainstream. Why is this you may ask? Well, only recently has the government had problems getting oil- or claims they are having problems (a whole different issue). The reason why coal and oil is so cheap is because it is highly government funded and subsidized. If the government bothered shifting its funding to different types of energy sources there would not need to be a whole “movement” to have the use of them widespread.

It is only logical to use renewable or clean energy from both an environmental and economic standpoint. The environmental benefits include:

  1. Zero emissions
  2. Minimal to no environmental impact
  3. No water pollution

1. Renewable energy resources do not emit carbon during energy conversion. As mentioned in a previous blogpost, fossil fuel plants are very inefficient. This leaves plenty of room for carbon to romp around warming our atmosphere.

2. When harvesting coal or natural gas, there is a great deal of land abuse. Mines are dug hundreds of feet inside mountains ruining the structure of the land. This destroys habitats of native species as well as makes the surrounding areas ugly. Also, do you want a coal burning plant near your home? I don’t! It smells and looks awful.

3. One repercussion of fossil fuels that many people neglect to consider is the pollution of water. Runoff from plants contaminates water supplies for humans and other animals. Renewable energy is clean and does not have any waste so there is little to worry about along the lines of water pollution.

Economically there are also several benefits which were spotlighted in the chapters in Green Urbanism called Living on Solar Income.

Solar energy is very unique as it will actually pay for itself within roughly 10-15 years. This means that if you install solar cells in your home now, in 15 years you will have saved a considerable amount on energy use. Also, many jobs are created as solar cells must be installed and maintained of the years.

An interesting aspect of renewable energy is to look at geothermal and nuclear (fusion) power. Even though these are two “almost renewable” types of energy what impact may they have on the environment. Geothermal power entails the drilling down hundreds of miles into the earth’s core to get heat which is converted to energy. What impact will this have on the earth and its internal temperature if any?

So, while being cautious around nuclear and geothermal energy, the other renewables seem very feasible and beneficial to society. Now, all it will take is the government to subsidize renewable energy and we no longer need to get “burned”.

Week 10/23

This whole semester we have discussed sustainability as a system that requires participation and dedication at all levels of society. Moreover, we have discussed the necessity of changing our patterns of consumption and creating a new paradigm of self-awareness and respect for the natural environment. In my mind, there is no better way to promote this paradigm than through religious institutions. Religious institutions have the power to shape world views, influence opinions, and captivate the minds of an open audience. Consequently, we should use these organizations as a resource as we seek to inform and educate the population about energy efficiency, economic multipliers, and the like. As Roseland suggests in his book Toward Sustainable Communities, interfaith coalitions can be a powerful tool for educating and informing the public. Specifically, he speaks about the Interfaith Coalition on Energy and how it has helped religious communities within Philadelphia reduce their energy consumption and adopt more sustainable systems of operation.

The Interfaith Coalition on Energy not only teaches congregations of all faiths how to upgrade their buildings and reduce energy use, but it also provides these congregations with ideas for funding such upgrades. Sadly, I was unable to obtain most of the literature that the coalition produces because the organization does not provide such literature for free. Although the coalition operates almost entirely off of money donated by individuals and congregations, it still requires that communities of faith pay for the services offered—services such as printed material (pamphlets and books) and workshops.

Interestingly enough, the Interfaith Coalition on Energy does not focus all of its attention on ecological sustainability awareness. Although the coalition’s website describes energy efficiency and reduction as a holy practice, it sells its services by highlighting the economic benefits of sustainable behavior. Specifically, the group helps religious congregations save money by improving energy efficiency and reducing energy consumption so that these congregations can invest more money into non-profit work and community services. For example, the coalition recommends that religious congregations purchase the least expensive energy that is available (even if the energy is produced by fossil fuels) and that the congregation continually hunt for lower prices. Despite this slightly discouraging practice, the coalition maintains a high level of commitment to the natural environment. Below I have posted the ten declarations that they use to justify sustainable energy choices.

Reasons for Congreations to use lesss energy:

Produce less atmospheric and water pollution
Set an example for others to follow
Strengthen families and communities
Using less of everything is spiritual – fasting, thrift, frugality, kindness, fairness
Lessen the expense and inconvenience of future generations who will have to live with the pollution and guard our nuclear waste resulting from our extravagance
Become more independent – freedom from dependence on electricity and gasoline
Slow chemical reactions on building structure and contents
Do what is right
Receive relatively high financial return on investments

Wind Cooperative Energy and Community Participation in Green Cities

For this week's assignment, I chose to read The Apollo Alliance's "New Energy for Cities" and Mark Roseland's chapter on Energy Efficiency and Renewables from "Toward Sustainable Communities." In the past, I have enjoyed reading Beatley's compendium of European-based sustainability initiatives, but this time I was drawn to look at some viable North American programs as well. I also enjoyed reading about so many different options in how sustainability is being addressed by different regions.

My readings this week continued to solidify an important lesson that has been formulated for me during this course: that sustainable cities require a diverse set of options in order to reduce their consumption and improve civic health. No one renewable resource, technology or green attitude will save an area from dependance from non-renewable resources. Rather, each community will have to diversify and look at a wide array of local options in order to move forward towards healthier systems. Increased community participation in civic decision-making and more social justice initiatives can help expand a region's green options by tapping into the knowledge and energy of a greater proportion of the population. Of course, creating site-specific and diverse sustainability options will tend to create very complex systems, but systems thinking approaches can help to sort this out and provide us with a deeper understanding of the immensely productive potential that ecological (and humans are included in this!) diversity can create.

Wind Turbine Cooperatives:

The Energy Efficiency and Renewables Chapter from "Toward Sustainable Communities" by Mark Roseland mentions cooperative wind turbines as an example of a useful green power program. The short paragraph focuses on Danish cooperatives that has joined together the efforts of over 150,000 Danish families and 6,300 wind turbines. The opportunity to research this amazing project was too good for me to pass up.

I am very interested in looking at wind power programs, particularly cooperative ones, because I think that such programs could be readily integrated into any regional power grid that has sufficient wind to operate a turbine. On an even more personal level, the precious growing area around my boyfriend's family farm is presently being threatened by plans to build a massive natural gas power plant. What better way to fight such an endeavor than to start a cooperative where the farmers can create and sell their own clean energy? The CREST (Center for Renewable Energy and Sustainable Technology) website claims that wind power is the fastest-growing green energy technology because it is the only one that can viably compete with fossil fuels in terms of cost.(www.crest.org)

One specific example of a Danish wind cooperative is the Working Group for Wind Turbines on Middelgrunden which was started in 1997. This project, located near Copenhagen, consists of twenty offshore turbines that are placed in a shallow area that was once used for dumping sludge and construction debris. The cooperative collaborated with Copenhagen Energy so that each organization built half the turbines. According to the project's website, "[t]he total effect of the wind farm will be 40 MW. The twenty 2000 kW turbines have a total estimated electricity production of about 89,000,000 kWh per year. This means that approximately 3% of the electricity consumption within the municipality of Copenhagen can be covered by these wind turbines."(www.middelgrunden.dk)

I found it interesting that the Middelgrunden wind turbines are placed offshore of Copenhagen. I have never seen offshore wind turbines in person, but I have often wondered why Toronto does not consider such an option in their quest for renewable energy sources. One of the arguments that I have heard against placing wind turbines offshore of the city is that people don't want such windmills marring their view of the water. I happen to think that wind turbines can be quite beautiful, and from the publicity statements from the Middelgrunden project, the Danish are very proud of both the energy production and aesthetic quality of the wind turbines. At this point, I think that the usefulness of wind turbines as a source of green power should outweigh our aesthetic condescensions. Well over 18% of Denmark's power supply now comes from the wind, and according to Wikipedia, Denmark isn't even all that windy! If Denmark can do this, why can't the United States and Canada?

Energy Efficiency- District Heating/Public Buildings

I found the two readings, “Energy Efficiency and Renewables” and Chapter 9 in Green Urbanism to be extremely useful. As I was reading these chapters, I kept thinking about how the different tools discussed could be applied to my own community. I decided to look into district more in depth, since before doing these readings I had never even heard of this method. So, I used Wikipedia (don’t judge! The article is referenced), and I now I better understand the concept of this system. Say you have a regular steam-electric power plant, where electricity is generated through the burning of fossil fuels to create steam to move a turbine. In this traditional mode of production, the process converts only 47% of the fuel into electricity; the rest is lost as heat, which gets dissipated into the plant’s surroundings. With districting heating, a cogeneration plant is used. In cogeneration, the heat that usually gets lost is trapped and used to heat homes nearby. The heat is transferred through insulated pipes, either in the form of hot water or steam. While this form of power generation does greatly reduce the amount of fuel needed to power and heat homes, it is very expensive to install. District heating would be practical in a new community with high density, but to implement it in an existing low density suburb would be silly.

One of the problems district heating is experiencing in the United States is that it is poorly funded and maintained by power plants. As a result, the quality of the systems has deteriorated and not as many people get their heat through cogeneration plants. However, “Energy Efficiency” mentions the fact that district heating doesn’t necessarily need a power plant to be viable. For instance, a new hospital or school could include a higher capacity heater, and the excess heat produced by the new building could be distributed to nearby residential developments. This is particularly significant to proposed communities like the SouthWest project in Ithaca. A district heating system could be installed in a community center or other public building and then used to power the more high-density buildings. The heating system could be community owned and operated, leading to greater neighborhood capacity and sustainability.

I really like the idea of using public buildings to set examples for the rest of an area. In Green Urbanism, the author mentions Colorado’s Rooftop for Schools Program. Besides setting a positive example, a program like this has the potential to help generate revenues for an area that can always use extra funds. While researching wind energy for my group project, I ran across an elementary school that installed a single windmill and was able to sell the excess energy it generated back into the power grid. The profit was used to make improvements to the school and generally create a better learning environment for the students. This whole bit got me thinking about the possibilities of installing solar roofs on public schools in Baltimore County and what that would mean for not just the schools, but the entire county. Parents would become more aware of solar options, and individual solar units might not seem as futuristic and unattainable.

Green Urbanism mentions how cities in Europe compete with each other for the title of most solar-oriented, and I feel that his type of mentality could easily be applied to the state of Maryland. Counties are constantly competing with each other for business and population, so why not compete with each other for leadership in sustainable options like solar power? Howard County has already appointed itself as the leading green county, and I have a feeling other county executives won’t be far behind in trying to claim this title.

most relevant

Getting the people inspired:

  • behavior change, community participation: Providing the community with a symbol of environmental mission for the citizens to share (i.e.; architecturally striking power plant that gives the citizens of Viborg, Denmark a source of pride (Beatley 261).) In another class, I remember reading from the book (also website) “WorldChanging” about a river in Seoul, Korea, that had been completely paved over for decades, but he city had instituted a project to uncover the river and develop its banks as public spaces, and giving the people their river back. The symbol the water, a life source, being resurrected, was incredibly inspiring for the citizens of Seoul.








              • behavior change, systems approach: Beatley’s example of the “political dynamic” in Germany that facilitates the implementation of renewable energies. This simultaneous top-down and bottom-up (there is also popular support from the German people) systems approach makes behavior change practically effortless.

              Carrot and/or stick:

              • behavior change: Beatley’s example of carbon tax (stick) in Sweden resulting in dramatic rise in use of biomass energy, which results in significant savings for the community (carrot).

              Public-Private sector partnerships:

              • systems approach, behavior change: Beatley’s example of the city of Heidelberg’s incentive-based contract with private companies which allows for the companies to keep a high percentage of the money saved from the energy-conservation measures, while a smaller percentage is reinvested in the city. (This is a similar strategy to the Case Presentation Carlos gave in class!) Roseland mentions this type of strategy as well; “economic multipliers”: monies that are saved on energy that are re-invested in the local economy and circulate several times over. This strategy is pure genius, it’s so frustrating that more U.S. cities haven’t realized the benefits of implementation.

              Making the renewable energy technology accessible:

              • systems approach, behavior change strategies, community participation: Beatley’s example of housekeepers and building managers put in charge of monitoring consumption meters.
              • behavior change, community participation: Giving citizens free/affordable equipment (i.e., Beatley’s example of Leiden’s energy company giving customers water conserving package of equipment).
              • justice/equity, behavior change, systems approach: Roseland’s several examples of “DSM” or “demand-side management” weatherization programs that improve energy-efficiency of homes and therefore affordability of energy costs for low-income people living in poorly constructed homes. This example is of particular importance to me, as I have worked with families living in transitional housing many of whom were dealing incredible debt just from energy bills near (no exaggeration) $1,000/month (!) because of the poor quality of their homes. I volunteered for the Tompkins County Healthy Homes Project and Weatherization Assistance Program over the summer and it was wonderful to see how the community’s investment in the homes turned into massive savings for the low-income residents.
              Synergistic Design that addresses multiple issues:

              • Biomimmicry: many designs that Beatley mentions provide more than one creative response to a need, just as organisms perform synergistically in nature, (i.e.; Beatley’s example of PVs integrated into road and highway noise barrier, and the various examples of cogeneration).
              • systems approach, community participation: Beatley’s example of the school in Nieuwland with mirrors that project a view of the green roof into the classroom so that the energy of the school becomes integrated into the teaching curriculum.
                Systems approach, biomimicry: Roseland talks about the six different areas of evaluation for the LEED Rating System. LEED is a systematic approach to ensuring a building’s sustainability, which, if successful, are often inherently designed in the likeness of a living organism.

              Saturday, October 20, 2007

              New York Climate Summit

              ** November 16-18, 2007 **
              ** Cornell University **

              WHAT: The New York Climate Summit will unite campus and community leaders to create a plan of action on how to pressure Albany to pass legislation requiring the state to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions 80% below 1990 levels by 2050.

              WHERE: Warren Hall, Cornell University

              CONTACT: Carlos Rymer, carlos.rymer@gmail.com

              VISIT: www.rso.cornell.edu/kyotonow